Boundaries Without Guilt: Why a Screen Door Is Still a Door
I had a client tell me once that she felt like a hallway. Everybody walked through her to get somewhere else. However, nobody stopped to see what was on the walls.
She had been raised to be helpful. When she was helpful, she got praised. Sometimes when she was helpful, it got her loved. Then other times it, at least, got her left alone. By the time she was in her forties, she could not tell the difference between being needed and being valued. She said yes to a baby shower she could not afford. Thanksgiving at her house, eight days after surgery, yes. A phone call at 11:40 at night from someone who only calls when something is on fire, yes. She was there, helped, did all she could, even to her detriment.
Then she came in and asked me, very seriously, if wanting one Saturday to herself made her a selfish person. If you have ever asked yourself some version of that question, keep reading. This one is for you.
Boundaries are Not Walls
Here is where most of us get stuck. We hear the word boundary and we picture a wall. Some people thin a boundary is a concrete wall with barbed wire on top. Us on one side and everybody we love on the other, and no way to get a message through.
So we do not set one because we are not wall people. We are the ones who show up with a casserole.
A Boundary is Not a Wall. It is a Screen Door.
Think about a real screen door on a real house in the spring. The air still moves through it and you can hear the kids in the yard. You can smell somebody’s grill two houses down. During the day, light comes in and the breeze. Also, love comes in and nobody is locked out of anything.
What a screen door does is make people knock. It slows things down just enough that you get to decide who comes in and when. The folks who walk in respectful are welcome to stay all afternoon. The ones who keep tracking mud through your kitchen have to wipe their feet or stay on the porch.
That is the whole thing. You do not have to get hard to get healthy. The reality is, is that you just have to put something between you and the world that lets you choose.
Your Body Knew Before You Did
I ask people all the time when they first noticed the resentment, and almost nobody can answer that. They can tell me when they noticed the headache, their jaw clenching, or the way their stomach dropped when a certain name lit up their phone.
Resentment is not a character flaw. It is a check engine light. The check engine light comes on when you have been giving past your capacity for long enough. There is some part of you that has started keeping score, even though you would never say that out loud.
Dread does the same thing. So does the exhaustion that sleep will not fix. There is also the snappiness that lands on the people who did not do anything. This usually lands on your spouse or your kids. That is because they are the safest ones to be short with. That is its own kind of heartbreak.
Your body has been telling you where the line is. You have just been talking over it.
Peel it back. When did you start saying yes with your mouth while everything in you was saying no?
The Guilt is Not Proof You Did Something Wrong
This is the part I wish somebody had told me twenty years ago (maybe forty years ago).
When you set a limit for the first time, you are going to feel awful. This isn’t just a little discomfort. It is awful. You will replay the conversation in the shower. There will be a follow-up text, drafted and deleted twice. You will start apologizing for a sentence that was not even unkind. Then, by bedtime, you have decided you were harsh and cold. Then you realize you are not the person your mama raised.
That feeling is real, and it is not evidence.
Guilt shows up when you break a rule. If you were raised on the rule that other people’s comfort matters more than yours, then keeping your own needs in the room is going to trip the alarm every single time. The alarm going off does not mean there is a fire. It means the wiring is old.
Give it a week. The guilt comes down. What is underneath it, usually, is relief. Then a little grief for all the years you did it the other way.
Say It Before You Have to Say It
Most people do not fail at boundaries because they lack conviction. They fail because the words are not in their mouth yet. The moment comes fast, they panic, and then they say yes.
So practice out loud. Do it in the car, the shower. Sound ridiculous on purpose.
“I can’t take that on right now.”
“I love you, and I’m not going to talk about this tonight.”
“Let me think about it and get back to you.” (You are allowed to not answer immediately. That is a complete option.)
“That doesn’t work for me.”
No is a complete sentence with a period at the end. Your no does not need a footnote, and your peace does not need a courtroom defense. Words feel a lot less scary the second time they come out of your mouth, so make the first time happen somewhere safe.
I Put All of It In a Book
I have been having this conversation in my office for years, over and over. It has been had with helpers, caregivers, peacekeepers, and the quiet ones. These are the ones who learned early to swallow disappointment so somebody else could feel comfortable. So I finally wrote it down.
The Screen Door: A 24-Day Boundaries Devotional and Journal for Loving People Without Losing Yourself is out now.
It is 24 days and it moves through four sections: understanding boundaries, listening to what your life is telling you, boundaries in relationships, and protecting peace and staying steady.
Each day has a scripture and a short devotional written like a conversation instead of a lecture. There is also a journal page with a reflection question. I also a gentle practice and room to write. There is a pause and reflect page for going deeper. Lastly, there is a closing encouragement to carry into your day.
In the back there are 24 Boundary Scripts. These are real sentences you can borrow and say out loud before you ever have to use them on a person.
The faith in it shows up the way it does at the kitchen table, not the way it does from a pulpit. Plain. Honest. Tender in some places and tough in others. This is how I actually talk.
It is not just for people with one difficult relative, either. It is for anybody who has family, friends, coworkers, church people, neighbors, or somebody at the gas pump with an opinion nobody asked for. So, all of us.
Pick it up. Sit with what stings. Peel it back. Find your voice and use it.
Baby steps. Progress over perfection.
Knowledge is power. When you know better, you do better.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you.
Related Posts
My Books: Faith-Filled Stories for Healing and Hope
