Choosing Presence Over Perfection

A perfectionist is never in the room. She’s four hours ahead of it, running the check. Is this going to turn out? I have to make sure everyone is happy. What still needs doing? Who needs more food? What will they think when they see it?
Her body is at the table however, she is not.
The trade
Nobody sat down and agreed to this, and it’s happening anyway. To keep a high standard, you have to monitor. In order to monitor, your attention has to be partly on the outcome. Attention is finite, so whatever goes to the outcome is not available for the moment you’re currently in.
That’s the trade. Quality of result for presence in the process. The exchange rate is worse than anybody realizes. I’ve watched women build a Christmas that their whole family remembers fondly and that she remembers as a blur of dread (speaking from experience). She (I) spent Christmas standing in the kitchen doorway assessing.
You can host or you can attend. In my experience, doing both at full volume is not on the menu.
Where it actually costs you
With your kids, it costs the thing you most want. They will not remember whether the birthday matched. They’ll remember whether you were fun that day. When you think about it, fun requires a person who isn’t scanning.
With your marriage, it costs ease. You cannot be close to somebody you’re evaluating. After enough years of being slightly evaluated, people get careful around you.
With yourself, it costs the good parts. You finish something, and the moment it’s done you’re looking at the flaw. Then, you’re on to the next thing. The satisfaction of the accomplishment that you earned, goes unclaimed. That’s a strange kind of poverty for a person who has built quite a lot.
Why we can’t put it down
Perfection is usually protection. For a lot of people, the standard came from a house where mistakes were expensive. Somebody got angry, or cold, or disappointed in a way that mattered. A child figured out that flawless was the safest place to stand.
For others, it’s about worth. If you’re only valuable when the output is exceptional, then every unfinished or imperfect thing is a threat to your standing.
For some, it’s simply that high standards have worked. You’ve been rewarded for this. People rely on you precisely because you don’t let things slide. Giving it up feels like giving up the thing that made you.
I’m not telling you to lower your standards across the board. I’m asking where you’d be willing to spend a little quality to buy back some presence.
The practice
Pick your good-enough list. Decide in advance which things in your life get an A and which get a B minus, on purpose. Most people have never consciously decided this, so everything gets the same effort and everything eats the same amount of them.
My supervisor told me, in my last year of school “You better not get a 4.0. Your goal is to finish, not perfection. What you will learn is what is in the field. You have to do what the professor needs from you. Do not give it more than you can attainable and sanely complete.” I have never had anyone tell me that. Quite the opposite when you grew up, with classmates, who called you stupid and you couldn’t do it.
Set a stop, not a standard. “I’m working on this until four” instead of “I’m working on this until it’s right.” Right is a moving target and it moves away from you as you approach.
Notice the moment you leave the room. You’ll feel it, once you start looking. A slight lean forward, a scan, a mental jump to the next thing. That’s the exit. Just noticing it brings you partway back.
Use your senses to return. What do I hear right now. What’s the temperature. What does the coffee actually taste like. Presence runs through the body, and the body is only ever in the present tense.
Let something stay unfinished in front of people. This is the hardest rep and the most valuable one.
Claim the thing you did. Out loud, once, before you move on. “I’m glad I did that.” Most high performers have never said that sentence about their own work.
The part about your kids
I want to say this directly to the mothers reading, because it comes up constantly. Your kids do not need you to be impressive. They need you to be there, available, and reasonably okay.
A child can tell the difference between a parent in the room and a parent managing the room. They can tell it at four years old and forty years old. What they take from the managed version is that something about them requires supervision, which is not at all what you meant.
Some of the best parenting I’ve ever seen happened in a messy house on an ordinary Tuesday with a mother who had stopped trying to make it look like anything.
The trade going the other way
Here’s what you get when you spend a little perfection to buy presence.
You remember things. Whole evenings instead of a checklist of how they went.
You laugh more, because laughing requires being here and not three hours out.
People relax around you, which changes what they bring you.
You get your own life back in the present tense, which is the only tense it’s ever actually available in.
Is this a hill to die on? Will it matter in a day, a week, a month? Ask it about the table setting, the email, the thing you’re about to redo. Then go sit down with the people while they’re still in the room.
This is education, not therapy. If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. If you’re in Kentucky and you can’t remember the last event you actually attended, let’s work on that. Circle of Hope Counseling Services.
Related Posts
The Quiet Beauty of Letting Go