|

Acting From Fear, Shame, or Anger

Couple sitting apart on a porch swing after an argument

Of all the feelings that try to drive the bus, three of them grab the wheel more than the rest. Those are fear, shame (here is our no-no word…likely it is guilt), and anger (remember, secondary to fear and/or sadness).

All three of them think they’re protecting you. Sometimes they are. When they’re the ones making the decisions, the protection usually costs a lot more than it’s worth.

When fear is driving

Fear wants to keep you safe, so it pushes you toward control. It looks like over-preparing, checking, double-checking, and needing to know where everybody is. It can look like clinging to a relationship you know isn’t good for you because being alone feels scarier.

Fear is also behind a lot of people pleasing. If I keep everybody happy, nobody will leave, nobody will yell, and I’ll be safe. Saying yes when you mean no feels like peace, but it’s really fear wearing an apron.

When shame is driving

Shame is the sneakiest of the three. Dr. June Tangney and other researchers have spent years studying the difference between shame and guilt, and it’s one of the most useful things I teach.

Guilt says, “I did something bad.” Shame says, “I am bad.”

That little difference changes everything. Guilt tends to move people toward repair. You apologize, you make it right, you do better. Shame tends to move people toward hiding, denying, blaming somebody else, or lashing out, because when it feels like your whole self is on trial, admitting anything feels like a death sentence.

So shame can look like lying about small things, perfectionism, avoiding people, or picking a fight right when someone gets close to the truth.

When anger is driving

Anger moves toward the threat. It pushes back, raises its voice, gets the last word, slams the cabinet door. Sometimes it goes cold instead and punishes with silence.

I tell couples about cauliflower ears. When somebody starts yelling, the person on the other end shuts down. Their ears close up like a wrestler’s. They aren’t listening anymore, they’re just defending. So you can be completely right and still not be heard at all, because of how you said it.

Dr. John Gottman found that the way a conflict conversation starts, in roughly the first three minutes, predicts how it’s going to end the large majority of the time. A harsh start almost always leads to a harsh finish.

Here’s something important, though. Anger is very often a guard dog standing in front of something softer. Under a lot of anger is hurt, fear, or shame that didn’t feel safe to show.

Find your voice

I say this to kids and grown-ups alike: find your voice, and use it to fight instead of your hands. You can be kind and have authority at the same time.

Using your voice means saying the real thing underneath. “I’m scared you’re going to leave.” “I felt embarrassed when you said that in front of your mom.” “I need you to stop.” It’s harder than yelling and harder than hiding. It’s also the only thing that actually gets you what you need.

It might feel clumsy the first few times. Your voice may shake. You might say it too softly, or start strong and then backpedal. That’s fine. Nobody finds their voice all at once. You find it a sentence at a time, and every time you say the real thing instead of swinging or hiding, it gets a little steadier.

Where are you?

After Adam and Eve ate the fruit, they hid. When God came walking in the garden, Adam said, “I heard Your voice in the garden, and I was afraid because I was naked; and I hid myself” (Genesis 3:10).

Fear and shame showed up together, and the first thing they did was hide. That’s still what they do.

But look at what God did. He came looking. Genesis 3:9 says He called out, “Where are you?” He knew where they were. He was inviting them to come out. He’s still asking the same question, and it isn’t a trap.

Questions to sit with

  • Which of the three, fear, shame, or anger, tends to drive your choices most?
  • When you’ve acted from that feeling, what were you trying to protect?
  • What softer feeling might be hiding under your anger?

One small step

The next time you notice yourself acting fast, maybe snapping, hiding, or rushing to fix, stop and ask two questions: “Which one is driving right now, fear, shame, or anger?” and “What’s the hurt underneath it?” Then, if it’s safe, say the hurt out loud instead of acting out the feeling.

Let’s walk this together

If fear, shame, or anger has been steering your relationships, that pattern can change. I work with individuals, couples, families, and teens at Circle of Hope Counseling Services, in person in Paducah and by telehealth across Kentucky.

This post is for education and encouragement. It isn’t therapy, and it doesn’t replace care from a licensed professional who knows your story. If you’re in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, any time, day or night. If you’re in immediate danger, call 911.

Related Posts

Small Acts of Letting Go That Build Trust

You Might Also Like